zhChinese    ruRussian
  AM&CP  » Resources  » Vestnik of SPbU  » For authors  » Order review

Order review

Reviewing procedure of scientific paper manuscripts received by the editors of the journal “Vestnik of St. Petersburg State University. Series 10.  Applied Mathematics. Computer Science. Control Processes

1. Review is mandatory for all research papers received by the Series 10 editorial board.

2. Editor in Chief and Executive Secretary of the series determines the compliance of the article with journal profile, the requirements for registration and send it for review by a specialist or a Ph.D., with specialization close to the topic of the article.

3. Reviewers are notified that manuscript is the private property of the authors, and contained information should not be disclosed. Reviewers are not allowed to copy the articles. Review is confidential.

4. Dates of review are determined by the Executive Secretary of the series.

5. The review must contain:

a) compliance of the article to its name, and

b) compliance of the article to high achievement in that field of science,

c) assessment of the form of the material,

d) the appropriateness of publishing,

e) a detailed description of the advantages and weaknesses of the article.

6. The author receives the text of the review. Violation of anonymity is possible only in the case of alleged plagiarism of a reviewer or falsification of materials contained in the article.

7. If the review contains recommendations for improving and finalizing the article, Executive Secretary of the series sends the text to the author with the proposal to take into account the recommendations in the preparation of a new draft of the article or refute them providing necessary reasons. Rewritten paper is send to next review iteration.

8. In the case where the reviewer does not recommend the article for publication, the editorial board may send article to be rewritten, taking into account the comments made, as well as send it to another reviewer. Text of the negative review is sent to the author.

9. The final decision of publication of an article is made by the editorial board of the series and recorded in the minutes of the meeting of the editorial board.

10. After the decisions on the admission of article for publication Executive Secretary of the series informs the author about the date of publication. Text of the review is sent to the author.

11. Review comments are stored in editorial board of the series for five years.